Do I Want To Be Dan Brown?

DanBrownI was asked an interesting question at the weekend, ‘would you rather be Dan Brown and make millions, or be critically acclaimed and scratch a living?’ I thought about it for a moment and then I realised how old my 6-year old was becoming.

But seriously, is this a relevant question for a new writer? Perhaps you can hide behind the stock response of, ‘I’ll write whatever’s inside me and leave it up to the market to decide which I am,’ but this sounds like a cop out to me. I’m all for planning where you want to get to and believing that it’s possible, so where am I heading?

The Millionaire Route

This would be nice, I’m not one of these pretentious people who believes that money, in some way, dilutes the quality of the art. As if being commercially successful detracts from the authenticity. This is a popular opinion held by bitter artists. Don’t get me wrong, there’s a difference between being successful and selling-out. The first happens if enough people like your work, the second happens if you try and give the people what you think they want.

Dan Brown has a formula and he knows that formula will sell a gazillion books every time. I can’t help but admire that. The formula, which was perfected in The Da Vinci Code, can now be rolled out every time. There’s two arguments here; firstly, it’s his formula that he created whilst being authentic to himself, but secondly, every subsequent time he uses that formula he’s kind of giving the people what they want. I can see both of these points of view.

Most successful authors find their formula and roll it out. Agatha Christie and PG Wodehouse were both guilty of this business model. James Herbert has a team of unknown writers churning his formula out. What’s wrong with making some money?

The Tortured Artist

To some, it’s more important to be a slave to your art and to concentrate on ‘The Craft’. It’s not a formula that you seek but critical acclaim instead for every book you produce. I personally think this is important to, what’s the point of doing something every day unless you harbour some kind of an ambition to get better at it.

To have the respect from your peers is a good thing. Without it you’d feel a fraud and after the first million had been banked, I think you would feel an emptiness if you didn’t have it. For example, JK Rowling is often criticised for her ‘craft’ and I reckon this was the reason why as soon as she had shed the albatross of Harry Potter, she went in a completely different direction. What’s the one thing missing from the most commercially successful author of all time? Peer respect.

But what did I say?

My first instinct as a new writer is to make enough money from this profession to support my family. Once I’ve hit that quite modest income I would then like people to say that I can actually write. So, it’s a halfway house for me.

I don’t understand why someone would write the novel that’s inside of them, ‘… just because I’ve got to get it out,’ if that book focuses on the nutritional diet of a stag beetle. No one will care and it won’t sell. You have to have a vague notion of what’s going to sell. It would be like opening a shop to sell left shoes, no point. Writing is a business and therefore requires its players to make money.

But… churning out guff in a concentrated niche that you know will sell, but has no relevance to you as an author, has to be frowned upon to.

Who would you rather be?


6 responses to “Do I Want To Be Dan Brown?

  1. I want to entertain. I want the person finishing something I’ve written to turn to their significant other, their friend, their child and say “Twas a good book that.” That’s why I write (and aspire to get something substantial out there). It needs to be ‘good’. It needs to be ‘entertaining’. But that means different things to different people AT DIFFERENT TIMES.

    Sometimes I want an Ian Banks, a Chiana Mielville, a Joe Abercombie. Other times a Dan Brown, a John Scalzi, a Lee Childs, a Richard Kadrey. One thing they all have in common though is that they weave a great tale. And, I think, they have done so to the best of their ability (some with poetic prose, some with incredible attention to detail, others still with imagination beyond mine – the best with all of the above) . That’s what I want to do.

    I want to be a storyteller who’s tried his best to tell a great story. To that end I wouldn’t mind telling the stories that Dan Brown does (although some of his stories are better than others…). But the only formula I’ll stick to is one that results in what I think is a great story.

    Great post.

  2. “My first instinct as a new writer is to make enough money from this profession to support my family. Once I’ve hit that quite modest income I would then like people to say that I can actually write.”
    Says it all, Michael.
    If you haven’t seen the interview, Stephen Colbert’s conversation with Brown nicely illuminated why Brown writes what he does.

  3. I had a ‘message’ I wanted the world to hear, so naturally I want my book to be a best seller. If it’s not, my message won’t be heard. I didn’t want to write a literary masterpiece, I wanted to write an easy-to-read story with characters that readers would get attached to.

    Now writing book number two, I want to do the same thing, but this time I don’t have a compelling need to inform the world about anything. Mobewan says it well – “I want the person finishing something I’ve written to turn to their significant other, their friend, their child and say “Twas a good book that.”’

    I’d really like to make lots of money, too! 🙂

  4. I would love to be wildly successful as an author – ,meaning I’d love for people to love my work that I loved creating. I realize that is somewhat of a fantasy though so I compromise – I wrote what was inside me and I am currently working on editing it to be a little more appealing to the masses.
    But enough about me and my writing – I stopped by to read your latest post because I think you have great opinions and let you know I’m nominating you for a Liebster Award. See my post for more details.

    • I think, judging by the comments, everyone is in the same place. Nobody wants to be a laughing stock but we’d all quite like to earn a nice bit of money too. There’s nothing wrong with that.

    • Sorry, by the way, I’m incredibly flattered that you have nominated me for a Liebster Award. I’ve already been fingered before, but I will definitely check your blog out. Thank you for the kind words.

What d'you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s